Obscuring even as it reveals, a successful suspense story will contain enough twists to keep a reader captivated, but not so many that the book can’t stick the landing. This is a hefty enough task on its own, but some of my favorite mysteries and thrillers are the ones that add another layer of setting, fixation or subculture to this already delicate dance.
Meticulously researched and magically specific, these types of novels promise not only compelling storylines, but also rich deep dives into an unexpected fascination or topic. The tangents are more than mere diversion; they build a robust, fully-realized world that educates as it entertains.
In my own book, Let’s Not Go Overboard Here, I use pop culture as a lens through which my main character filters the world—and the shady behavior—around her. These are six other novels that take the reader on a thrilling, immersive trip down the rabbit hole.
*
Belinda Bauer, The Impossible Thing
This unique, fantastically-written mystery by Belinda Bauer had me talking my friend’s husband’s ear off about rare egg trafficking at a party a few months ago. Alternating between present day and the 1920s, The Impossible Thing cracks open the strange, high-stakes world of the illegal guillemot egg trade.
From the people who descend into madness obsessing over them, to the brave souls who dangle off sheer cliff faces to collect them, to the birds who create them, Bauer paints an unforgettable portrait of these impossible, beautiful treasures. I couldn’t google “what does a rare guillemot egg look like” fast enough.
Colson Whitehead, Harlem Shuffle
Written by one of the most talented novelists working today, it is unsurprising that Harlem Shuffle, the first in a historical fiction crime trilogy from Colson Whitehead, is incredibly compelling and entertaining. Whitehead brings 1960s Harlem to vivid life on the page, following protagonist Ray Carney as he falls into schemes and heists in his quest for more.
However, in addition to the excellent writing, Harlem Shuffle also serves as a crash course on a niche subject: 1960s furniture. Carney is a furniture salesman, and in addition to the intrigue on the page, the reader is treated to an immersive education on vintage sectionals. You’ll never look at a couch the same way.
Ross Montgomery, The Murder at World’s End
Another historical mystery, The Murder at World’s End by Ross Montgomery looks to the heavens for its central fascination. The year is 1910, and protagonist Steven Pike arrives at remote Tithe Hall for his new role as under-butler just as the world is caught in a frenzy of fascination and terror about the passing of Halley’s Comet. When he falls under suspicion for murder, he partners up with cantankerous octogenarian Decima Stockingham to clear his name. Decima, however, is much more interested in tracking the comet’s path.
Interspersed with real news articles from the time chronicling the worldwide hysteria wrought by the rare appearance of this celestial body, the novel does a wonderful job of intertwining scientific exploration with personal stakes.
Ayesha Manazir Siddiqi, The Centre
The field of translation is taken to disturbing ends in The Centre, this modern gothic thriller from Ayesha Manazir Siddiqi. It follows Anisa Ellahi, an adrift translator who enrolls in the titular Centre, a mysterious translation school that promises total fluency in your language of choice in only ten days.
An unsettling, harrowing spiral ensues, with a twist that I won’t spoil. By taking her interrogation of language exchange, appropriation, and colonialism to thrillingly creepy extremes, Siddiqi wraps a robust education on the world of translation in an un-putdownable package.
Amity Gaige, Heartwood
Heartwood by Amity Gaige begins with the disappearance of Valerie Gillis, aka Sparrow, somewhere in the remote wilderness surrounding the Maine stretch of the Appalachian Trail. Leading the search for Sparrow is Lt. Bev, whose passion and dedication to her craft know no bounds.
Gaige paints a lush, terrifying picture of the Maine wilderness, laying bare the grit it takes to hike the Appalachian Trail and the grit it takes to find those who get lost doing it. I don’t foresee myself ever attempting the Appalachian Trail, and I foresee myself volunteering for a wilderness search party even less, but for a moment Gaige’s incredibly-researched tale made me believe I could do it.
Kaliane Bradley, The Ministry of Time
Kaliane Bradley’s The Ministry of Time is a completely original genre-bending novel that explores time travel in a wholly unique way. It is beautifully written and offers powerful meditations on history, memory, and legacies of violence. It also is engrossed by Franklin’s lost Arctic expedition, and one member of that unlucky party in particular: Commander Graham Gore.
Bradley rockets Gore into the twenty-first century, and what ensues is an improbable yet heart-wrenching love story between Gore and the novel’s unnamed protagonist. Readers are given an unexpected window into Franklin’s ill-fated voyage, a real-life tragedy that is made all the more affecting by the incredible job Bradley does of bringing Gore to life.
***
